Data center sales tax incentives come under debate
Regional News
Audio By Carbonatix
1:15 PM on Thursday, November 19
(The Center Square) – The cost of state and local state tax breaks for data centers in Ohio is skyrocketing, according to one non-profit group, and has cost the state’s public schools $374 million annually.
Ohio started granting the state and local sales tax exemptions in 2013 for data center purchases of equipment and construction materials, according to the study by Policy Matters Ohio, a progressive think operating in Cleveland and Columbus.
Other groups, however, support the limited use of sales tax incentives with negotiated community benefits.
When the tax exemptions were first enacted, “they were designed for an earlier era of smaller data centers and are ill-equipped for the explosion of hyperscale facilities across the state,” according to the study. “Since then, the state has signed agreements with the largest technology companies – Amazon, Google, Meta, and Microsoft.”
Amazon’s exemption, according to the study, was signed in 2014 and lasts for the next 40 years.
“When the contract was signed, the state agreed to provide Amazon with an estimated $77 million in sales tax breaks in exchange for $1.1 billion in investment,” the study states. “In late 2024, the company announced an additional $10 billion investment and said it would invest a total of $23 billion by 2029.”
But with increased investment comes higher tax breaks.
Policy Matters Ohio estimated the actual Amazon subsidy might be 20 times more expensive than originally estimated.
Earlier this year, Gov. Mike DeWine directed the Ohio Tax Credit Authority to suspend any new data center tax exemptions.
"I fully support the Ohio General Assembly's work to study the issue and bring forward facts about data centers, including the local benefits to communities when tax exemptions are granted," DeWine said in a statement.
In its study, Policy Matters Ohio calls for making the governor’s temporary pause permanent.
Ohio currently has 262 data centers, according to the website DataCenterMap.
The Buckeye Institute, a conservative think tank in Columbus, supports the sales tax exemptions for goods used in manufacturing, Greg Lawson, institute senior research fellow, told The Center Square.
“This is because a sales tax should only be applied at the point of sale of the final good or service,” Lawson said. “If you apply it to intermediate goods used to make a final good or service you effectively raise the price of that good or service. This applies to data centers as well because servers and other equipment used inside are not the final good or service, data storage or AI training is. Thus, the sales tax would increase these costs.”
But he added the tax breaks “deserve hard scrutiny” because they shift costs onto residents.
“They should be used sparingly and if they are used, they should be limited in size and length, and communities should negotiate direct benefits, such as payments to the community, before construction begins,” Lawson said.